Publications
A comprehensive long term monitoring system of an iconic heritage complex: the Assisi Basilica case study
A long-term monitoring system implemented on the bell tower of Assisi's Basilica reveals critical insights into the dynamic behavior and seismic vulnerability of monumental structures. The study, conducted between 2022 and 2023, utilized a network of ultra-low-noise accelerometers and a velocimeter to track modal behavior, assess impacts from recent seismic events, and analyze weather-induced frequency variations. Data managed via cloud-based platforms highlights the tower's response to complex loading conditions, offering a model for preserving heritage sites in seismically active regions. This research advances understanding of long-term structural integrity under dynamic stresses.
"Genova e i Genovesi a Palermo": il patrimonio storico-artistico dalle celebrazioni del IV Centenario della fondazione della Chiesa di San Giorgio dei Genovesi alla sua ricostruzione virtuale
A groundbreaking digital reconstruction of the historical and artistic contributions of Genoa to Palermo, Italy, has been achieved through virtual reenactment. This study presents two innovative digital solutions: an immersive virtual exhibit on ArtSteps and an interactive 3D tour, which revisit key sites such as the Basilica of San Francesco d’Assisi and the Church of San Giorgio dei Genovesi, while incorporating new attributions from the past 50 years. The research leverages archival documentation, photographic evidence, and testimonies to update and expand understanding of Genoese patronage in Sicily, setting a new standard for Digital Art History. By digitally 're-locating' images from the 1978-79 exhibition within a photogrammetric model of Palazzo Ducale’s Salone del Maggior Consiglio, this work bridges historical celebration with modern technological innovation.
Giotto e la costruzione dello spazio. Le Storie di San Francesco nella Basilica Superiore di Assisi
Giotto's frescoes in the Basilica of San Francesco, Assisi, mark a revolutionary shift in artistic representation by integrating architectural space into narrative and symbolic storytelling. Unlike previous decorative uses, Giotto's work introduces volumetric and perspective techniques that redefine how architecture is depicted in art. The 'Storie di San Francesco' cycle, completed in the mid-14th century, serves as the first comprehensive example of this innovation, blending classical traditions with a new spatial conception. This study examines these frescoes through digital surface analysis, revealing their dual role as both an organizational structure for real space and a tool to explore the interplay between architectural design and figurative narration.
St. Francis/San Francesco
The Basilica di San Francesco in Assisi, Italy, utilizes local Subasio limestone to symbolize the duality of St. Francis and Christ through its architectural design and coloration. The study reveals that the basilica's double construction—mimicking the earthly body of St. Francis and the divine body of Christ—reflects late medieval and early modern religious symbolism, particularly the stark contrast between black and white. This analysis connects the basilica’s materials, plan, and function to contemporary writings about St. Francis’ incorruptible, dazzling white corpse, exploring themes such as Francis/Christ, church/body, and earthly/divine dichotomies.
Theology and Topophilia in Sacred Spaces: John Bradburne’s Way of the Water
John Bradburne's poetic exploration of sacred spaces and waters reveals a profound correlation between theology and topophilia, rooted in Franciscan and Marian devotion. His life, marked by ecstatic visions and mystical experiences, was deeply intertwined with water sources—from the Lake District to Assisi, Lourdes, and beyond—creating spaces of purification and contemplation. Bradburne's practice of bathing patients at the Mutemwa leper colony and his own rituals on Mount Chigona during Zimbabwe's civil war underscored the sacred significance of these waters. Posthumously, Mount Chigona emerged as a pilgrimage site, symbolizing the enduring influence of his mystic journey. This study charts Bradburne’s devotion, the sacralization of spaces, and the role of water in shaping his spiritual legacy.
Power of Patrons: The Franciscan Influence on Pietro Lorenzetti’s Passion Cycle at Assisi
Pietro Lorenzetti's Passion Cycle frescoes at the Assisi Basilica, completed during the Trecento Renaissance period (1306–1340), exemplify the profound influence of Franciscan patronage on religious and artistic pilgrimage. The Lower Church, serving as St. Francis of Assisi's burial site since 1230, transformed from a purely religious destination to one also revered for its Renaissance art and architecture after Lorenzetti's frescoes adorned both the Upper and Lower Churches. This shift underscored the basilica's dual significance—spiritual and aesthetic—contributing to its 1997 designation as a UNESCO World Heritage Site. Despite scarce records on Lorenzetti's life (born c. 1280–1290 in Siena) and his works (only five signed, often misspelled), the Passion Cycle stands as a testament to Franciscan influence on Renaissance art, blending religious devotion with artistic innovation.
The Legacy of the Basilica of San Francesco in Assisi in Franciscan Texts, c. 1305. Three Contrasting Assessments
A re-evaluation of the Sacrum commercium beati Francisci cum Domina Paupertate reveals it as a sharp critique of 13th-century Franciscan practices, not just a narrative about Francis and his brothers. This interpretation contrasts with earlier views, highlighting its role in symbolizing the betrayal of early Franciscan ideals embodied in the Basilica of San Francesco. The study analyzes Ubertino da Casale's 1305 critique alongside two other period testimonies—Jacopone da Todi’s laude and Giles of Assisi’s story—to explain why Ubertino omitted a polemical critique of the basilica despite its significance.
Building paradise on the Hill of Hell in Assisi: Mountain as reliquary
This study reveals how the burial of St. Francis of Assisi's remains on Mount Subasio transformed a once-wild, mountainous landscape into a sacred pilgrimage site, reshaping human-mountain dynamics and creating a lasting religious monument. It explores the paradoxical life of St. Francis—who rejected wealth and scholarship yet became a pivotal figure in Christian thought—and examines how his burial practices influenced community activities and perceptions of the mountain. The research centers on themes of bodies, burials, and bones, analyzing how these elements shape and are shaped by mountainous landscapes, particularly through the lens of 'conversations' between people and place. By integrating historical events with landscape analysis, the study offers a unique perspective on the mythic entwinement of human stories and sacred geography.
Restoration Techniques and Aseismic Reinforcement for Disaster Recovery of the Basilica San Francesco in Assisi, Italy
A groundbreaking seismic reinforcement approach successfully revitalized the Basilica of San Francesco in Assisi, Italy. The restoration integrated innovative technologies such as Shape Memory Alloy Devices and Shock Transmitters Units with steel belts, alongside traditional spring dampers for cross arches. These advancements were rigorously tested and validated through experimental data, offering a scalable solution for preserving historic structures against seismic disasters. The study emphasizes the importance of continuous technological innovation in disaster recovery, providing a model for future applications in other heritage buildings.
Bonaventure and the Maestro di San Francesco
Research suggests that the artistic decoration of Assisi's Basilica of San Francesco, particularly the scene of St. Francis' stigmatization, may reflect the theological thinking of Bonaventure, a prominent Franciscan leader who visited the site during his tenure as minister general. This finding implies that the artwork could date to after the completion of Bonaventure's influential work, the Legenda Maior. The study also highlights the significance of a large dated crucifix in Perugia, though its direct connection to Bonaventure remains less certain. By analyzing Franciscan art from this period, scholars aim to identify potential influences of Bonaventure's theological ideas on visual representation.
Crowd evacuation analysis of the Papal Basilica of Saint Francis in Assisi, Italy
A simulation model of crowd evacuation in the Papal Basilica of Saint Francis in Assisi reveals that optimizing exit flow can significantly reduce stationary waiting times and lower the risk of spontaneous panic during emergencies. The study, conducted by Garzia et al. (2019), analyzed the interaction between the basilica's architecture and visitor behavior to improve safety for millions of annual pilgrims and tourists. The findings provide actionable insights for managing evacuations in this UNESCO World Heritage Site, balancing cultural heritage preservation with modern safety engineering.
Catherine M. Mooney. Clare of Assisi and the Thirteenth-Century Church: Religious Women, Rules, and Resistance.
A remarkable textile discovery at the Basilica of San Francesco in Assisi reveals that Clare of Assisi, a close follower of St. Francis, mended his worn tunic with patches from her own garment over several years. This interlaced history symbolizes the intricate relationship between Clare and Francis, which has historically overshadowed their individual struggles and contributions. Catherine M. Mooney's study, 'Clare of Assisi and the Thirteenth-Century Church: Religious Women, Rules, and Resistance,' aims to re-examine Clare and her community at San Damiano independently while situating them within the broader networks of religious men and women that shaped the Order of St. Clare. Through a micro-study approach, Mooney explores the contested nature of regulating penitent women in the 13th century, offering new insights into their agency and influence.
"Things Not Seen" in the Frescoes of Giotto: An Analysis of Illusory and Spiritual Depth
Giotto di Bondone's frescoes employ hidden and omitted spatial elements to convey psychological and spiritual depth, demonstrating his unique visual wit (ingegno) that transcends superficial imitation. This study reveals how Giotto's narrative compositions in the Arena Chapel, Bardi and Peruzzi Chapels, and the Basilica of San Francesco in Assisi use architectural divisions and implied narrative perspectives to evoke emotional states and divine presence. Unlike prior research that only briefly addresses spatial composition, this analysis highlights Giotto's innovative approach, showing how his stylistic influence persists beyond Padua while eluding deeper replication by imitators.
The Making of Assisi: The Pope, the Franciscans, and the Painting of the Basilica by Donal Cooper and Janet Robson
A groundbreaking re-evaluation of the frescoes in Assisi's Basilica of San Francesco challenges traditional views on patronage and authorship, revealing that the pictorial program was shaped more by local Franciscan leaders—specifically Provincial Ministers and Custodians—than by Pope Nicholas IV or the Curia. Through meticulous prosopographical analysis and a fresh visual examination of the murals' context within the basilica, Cooper and Robson demonstrate that the frescoes evolved dynamically during their creation (1288–1297), reflecting a collaborative workshop driven by intellectual and administrative expertise rooted in Assisi's Franciscan community. This work reframes the role of Nicholas IV as a commissioner rather than a primary influencer, advancing understanding of the frescoes' conceptualization and execution.
The new communication network for an internet of everything based security/safety/general management/visitor's services for the Papal Basilica and Sacred Convent of Saint Francis in Assisi, Italy
A groundbreaking communication network leveraging the Internet of Everything (IoE) has been successfully implemented at the UNESCO World Heritage Site, the Papal Basilica and Sacred Convent of Saint Francis in Assisi, Italy. This innovative system integrates smart sensors, wearable devices, and data analytics to enhance visitor security, safety, and accessibility, including for individuals with disabilities. The network also supports cultural heritage preservation and operational management for site personnel, such as the Friar's community. By connecting people, things, and processes, this IoE-based solution addresses complex challenges posed by high-traffic sites like Assisi, which attracts millions of pilgrims annually. The study demonstrates how advanced technologies can be harnessed to protect and manage culturally significant locations while improving visitor experiences.
Picturing the Founder. A New Reading of the Stories of St. Benedict in the Lower Church of Sacro Speco at Subiaco.
A comparative analysis of the frescoes depicting St. Benedict's life in the lower church of Sacro Speco at Subiaco reveals significant parallels with the Franciscan cycle in Assisi, suggesting a deliberate artistic and theological dialogue between traditional monasticism and the new mendicant orders post-Council of Lyons (1274). The study identifies stylistic similarities beyond those previously noted, proposing that these frescoes—one of the earliest large-scale cycles about St. Benedict—were strategically positioned to engage viewers along a pilgrimage route, reinforcing Subiaco's role as a counterpoint to Assisi's Franciscan narrative. The research employs iconographic and contextual analysis to argue for an intentional contrast between monastic and mendicant ideals during this pivotal period of religious reform.
The Dynamic Behavior of the Basilica of San Francesco in Assisi Using Simplified Analytical Models
A critical factor in the collapse of two vaults in Assisi's Basilica of San Francesco during the 1997 earthquake was identified: cumulative structural changes, particularly roof retrofitting. Using simplified analytical models, researchers demonstrated that modifications to the roof, especially a 1958 intervention, stiffened the structure, redistributing seismic loads onto the façade and transept. This overload likely contributed to the vaults' failure. The study highlights how historical interventions can inadvertently alter a structure's dynamic behavior, increasing vulnerability to seismic events.
ToF‐SIMS study of gilding technique in the fresco Vela della Castità by Giotto's school
A Time of Flight Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) study on the fresco Vela della Castità by Giotto's school, located in Assisi's San Francesco Lower Basilica, reveals the chemical composition of its gilding technique. The analysis identified azelaic, palmitic, and stearic acids, confirming the use of an oil-resin binder between plaster and tin leaf, as well as colophony resin as an adhesive. This non-invasive method complements findings from other techniques like SEM-EDX and FTIR, providing a deeper understanding of medieval gilding practices on frescoes.
Holy Matter: Changing Perceptions of the Material World in Late Medieval Christianity
A groundbreaking exploration of late medieval Christian attitudes toward the material world reveals that, contrary to conventional views, many religious thinkers embraced a doctrine of 're-creation' enabled by Christ's incarnation. Sara Ritchey's study demonstrates that holy women's writings and Franciscan texts, particularly those centered on trees and crucifixion imagery, framed nature not as an obstacle but as a medium for divine manifestation. The research employs close textual analysis of works like the Speculum virginum, Hildegard of Bingen's writings, and Franciscan lives, alongside comparative examination of contrasting theological perspectives (e.g., Herrad of Hohenbourg). Key findings include the virginal body's role as an 'engine of incarnation' and the crucifixion's centrality in Clare of Assisi's vision of a redeemed material order. The study challenges secularizing eco-critical narratives, arguing that medieval religious culture perceived matter as inherently sacred, with implications for environmental humanities.
Images-within-Images in Italian Painting (1250–1350): Reality and Reflexivity by Péter Bokody (review)
Italian painting between 1250 and 1350 underwent a transformative shift, moving from Byzantine influence to developing its own identity and embracing spatial realism. Péter Bokody's study, rooted in his doctoral research, highlights this period's significance as the precursor to Renaissance art, focusing on artists like Giotto, Duccio, Simone Martini, and the Lorenzettis. The book explores how images-within-images, or 'parargon,' contributed to realism through trompe l’oeil, architectural illusionism, and meta-painting, while also examining Barthes’s 'reality effect.' Bokody's chronological analysis, centered on Assisi's frescoes, reveals the layered meanings in these works and their influence on later Netherlandish painting. The study avoids attributional debates but offers a fresh perspective on this pivotal era in Italian art history.
The dynamic behaviour of the roof interventions in the Basilica San Francesco in Assisi
Research reveals that roof interventions in the Basilica of San Francesco, Assisi, significantly altered its seismic response during the 1997 Umbria-Marche earthquake. These modifications decreased the structure's fundamental period, redirecting seismic loads toward the façade and transept, likely contributing to the collapse of two Gothic vaults. The study employed a simple analytical model to assess how changes in roof stiffness and mass over centuries influenced the basilica's dynamic behavior during the second shock. Findings suggest that cumulative damage from previous earthquakes and retrofitting interventions may have played a critical role in the 1997 collapse, highlighting the complex interplay between historical modifications and seismic vulnerability.
Armut und geistiger Aufstieg. San Francesco und Dante
This study reveals the complex interplay between artistic representation, spiritual poverty, and material wealth, particularly through the lens of San Francesco's life as depicted by Giotto and Dante. It examines how Giotto's portrayal of 'Poverty' in the Basilica of San Francesco contrasts with Dante's literary representation in the Paradiso, where San Tommaso d'Aquino's discourse deviates from the strict 'sine glossa' rule, incorporating self-commentary to clarify his hermetic style. The research highlights a tension between religious ethics and artistic vision, as Dante uses vivid topographical imagery—such as the Arno and Tevere rivers—to evoke material richness while exploring the allegorical ascent of 'Poverty' alongside Beatrice. This analysis opens a critical space for understanding how Dante's work bridges spiritual ideals with tangible cultural contexts.
The Her.cul.es International Summer Seminar
Participants of the Assisi Summer Seminar 'Tourism Management at World Heritage Site' provided insights into effective methodologies and assigned tasks for managing tourism at UNESCO World Heritage Sites, specifically focusing on Assisi's Basilica of San Francesco and other Franciscan sites. The seminar, held in July 2013, aimed to explore practical approaches to sustainable tourism management while preserving cultural heritage. By adopting a participatory perspective, the report offers valuable lessons for balancing visitor experience with site conservation, particularly relevant for World Heritage Sites facing increasing tourism pressures.
De middeleeuwse bedelordearchitectuur in Nederland
Mendicant architecture in the Netherlands, from the 13th to the early 16th century, exhibited distinct characteristics that set it apart from parish and collegiate churches. The study reveals a preference for simplicity, with buildings lacking towers, transepts, or radiating chapels, and using economical materials like stone, brick, and wood. Despite this 'poverty' in structural elements, the interiors were adorned with rich furnishings, including tombs, altars with retables, stained glass windows, and paintings, often gifted by burghers and confraternities. The research, based on a two-year fellowship at Leiden University, analyzed 57 friaries across 43 Dutch towns, using dendrochronological studies and archaeological excavations to reconstruct the growth process of these churches. It identified two main building waves: an early phase with aisled basilicas featuring polygonal choirs and ribbed vaults, and a later 15th-century wave dominated by hall-churches with wooden barrel vaults. The study also highlighted the functional division between the choir for liturgical offices and the preaching area for public use, including burials and civil meetings.
Francesco e Innocenzo III ad Assisi: riflessioni sull’iconografia francescana della missione evangelizzatrice
A renowned scene from Giotto's frescoes in Assisi, 'La conferma della regola,' depicts St. Francis receiving papal approval for his order's rule from Pope Innocent III. This study reveals that Giotto likely incorporated subtle visual cues to emphasize the evangelizing mission assigned by the pope while also hinting at the formalization of a written rule. The analysis suggests two key cultural references—imperial reception scenes and the 'Traditio legis' tradition—were used by Giotto, reflecting his medieval artistic imagination. These insights shed light on the ideological and iconographic choices behind this masterpiece, offering a deeper understanding of its historical and religious significance.
You are here:
World Heritage Explorer > World Heritage Research > World Heritage Sites > Assisi, the Basilica of San Francesco and Other Franciscan Sites